Can Text Messages Be Used in an Ohio Divorce Case?

man is holding phone

When a marriage ends, digital communication can become evidence in court. Text messages – the time they were sent, the tone, and even what was left unsaid – can play a surprising role in divorce cases in Ohio. Whether you are considering filing for divorce or have already been served with papers, understanding how judges treat text messages can significantly influence your strategy.

Practice Areas
Contact Us

Ohio Courts and Digital Evidence

Ohio courts regularly consider digital communication, such as text messages, emails, and social media posts, as potential evidence in divorce and custody cases. However, a text message alone does not automatically become evidence in court. Under the Ohio Rule of Evidence 901, all evidence must be authenticated before it can be admitted into court. This means that you must prove that the message is what you claim it to be.

Authentication typically involves:

  • Verifying the phone number or contact name associated with the other party.
  • Ensuring that the messages sent and received are consistent and identify the sender.
  • Receiving testimony from someone who has personal knowledge of the communication.
  • Using metadata such as timestamps and device information (when available) to help verify the authenticity of the messages.

Courts have a wide range of options here, and opposing lawyers will look for any gaps in the chain of custody or reasons to question the authenticity.

The Hearsay Question

Even authenticated text messages face a second obstacle: hearsay. According to the Ohio Rule of Evidence 802, statements made outside of court that are offered for the truth of the matter are generally not admissible as evidence. 

However, there are some exceptions for text messages. For instance, under Rule 803, certain types of statements, such as admissions by a party, excited utterances, or present-sense impressions, can be used as evidence in court.

What Text Messages Can Prove in an Ohio Divorce

Under Ohio Revised Code Chapter 3105, courts take into account a range of factors when deciding on property division, spousal support, and custody. Text messages can be considered relevant evidence in these areas:

  • Parenting fit: Messages that reveal substance abuse, neglect, or erratic behavior may weigh heavily in decisions about the best interests of the child under Ohio Revised Code § 3109.04.
  • Marital misconduct: While Ohio is a no-fault divorce state, actions such as the dissipation of marital assets can still be relevant to property division. Texts can document these actions.
  • Spousal support: Messages revealing undisclosed income, financial arrangements, or new relationships may factor into support calculations.
  • Credibility: When a spouse’s testimony in court contradicts their text messages, the court takes note, and it affects the weight given to everything they say.

How to Preserve Text Evidence Properly

lawyer is working with documents

Deleting text messages after a divorce case has been filed, or even if you reasonably anticipate legal proceedings, can be considered the destruction of evidence, which Ohio courts take very seriously. To properly preserve messages:

  • Take clear, time-stamped screenshots and save them to a secure and private location.
  • Do not alter, edit, or delete the messages in any way.
  • Keep the contact information visible in the message thread.
  • Notify your attorney about the messages as soon as possible – they can advise you on formal steps for preservation.

It is equally important to be careful about how you access messages. Ohio law prohibits accessing another person’s private information without their permission. ORC § 2913.04 governs unauthorized use of computer systems, and any evidence obtained in this way can be excluded – and may lead to criminal charges.

Speak With an Ohio Divorce Attorney First

Text message evidence can be a double-edged sword. While the messages you send might help your case, they could also contain information that could be used against you. Before you present or attempt to gather any digital evidence, it’s best to discuss the full situation with an experienced Ohio family law attorney. They can help you assess the relevance, admissibility, and potential risks in your specific case.

At Axelrod & Hellier LLP, we offer free consultations and a personalized approach to each client. If you would like to learn more about our services, please contact us to schedule a consultation.